SCORING ADDITION...

Oompa Midgets · Post by **Oompa Midgets** » Mon Apr 25, 2005 3:18 pm

kickers are outcasts in our fantasy league, but i know a way to make them more valuable!!!

simply count their yardage of the field goal, and multiply it like our offensive yardage...example (48-yard FG = 4.8 points)
i also believe they should get -1 for a missed FG or EP!!!

I LOVE THIS IDEA!!!
WHAT DOES EVERYONE ELSE THINK???
kickers are normally worthless, but this would make them more valuable!
i know some teams have gone thru the entire draft w/o drafting a kicker and this would stop that!!!

thechosenone · Post by **thechosenone** » Tue Apr 26, 2005 7:34 am

only if we give negative points though for missed attempts

Oompa Midgets · Post by **Oompa Midgets** » Tue Apr 26, 2005 11:20 am

looks like most people like the kicker restructuring...

Post by **wolfe** » Tue Apr 26, 2005 7:39 pm

HOLD ON THERE!

After voting "Yes", I decided I would investigate. This proposal only gives a modest increase in fantasy points. Look at the point totals below.

Code: Select all

Name           Proposed Current
Vinatieri, Adam  161.6  151.1
Elam, Jason      137.7  129
Reed, Jeff       131.7  128
Graham, Shayne   141.1  128
Akers, David     144.5  124
Lindell, Rian    114.5  123
Vanderjagt, Mike 123.7  123
Longwell, Ryan   131.2  122
Kaeding, Nate    120    118

Take Vinatieri's stat line, for example.
FG 31-33; XP 48-48
Points with current formula 31x3 + 48 = 141 (he obviously received some passing and tackling points)

For the proposed formula his sucessful FG lengths were:
32,43,29,28,24,42,40,40,39,30,41,27,43,25,43,31,45,36,27,24,20,45,37,37,28,28,40,48,28,29,26
That's a total of 1055 yards.

So his proposed total would be 1055*0.1 - 2*1 + 48 - 0*1 = 151.5

His average kick was about 34 yards. If given 0.1 point for each yard that's only slightly better than the 3.0 points received now.

Oompa Midgets · Post by **Oompa Midgets** » Tue Apr 26, 2005 9:09 pm

slightly is still better than nothing!!!
would it be a problem to change in the software jeff???

The Guru · Post by **The Guru** » Wed Apr 27, 2005 4:29 am

Hold everything Jeff has convinced me to change my vote too.

Jonathan S. · Post by **Jonathan S.** » Wed Apr 27, 2005 7:12 am

Why can't we leave something the same for once for God sakes. VOTE NO.

Agitator · Post by **Agitator** » Wed Apr 27, 2005 9:01 am

i'll vote which ever way has the most people.....

Oompa Midgets · Post by **Oompa Midgets** » Wed Apr 27, 2005 12:21 pm

bc kickers SUCK in this league!!!
why might as well not even have them!

how has jeff convinced u???
i thought we wanted more production from the kickers?
it still makes them more valuable...don't deduct for misses adds a few more points...

Jonathan S. · Post by **Jonathan S.** » Wed Apr 27, 2005 2:45 pm

I'm not changing my vote from NO-NO-NO.

MTFFL

SCORING ADDITION...

Are you in favor of this scoring change for kickers???

SCORING ADDITION...